So
here is my essay pitch. . . . .
I
would like to write my essay on The Tale of Genji. So I have a few different angles I could approach
this essay from.
1.
Exploring what it means to be a man ---- and feminized
In
The Epic of Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh is
feminized is specific and impactful ways.
Both his physical appearance and actions are described in feminine
way. He loves Enkidu as a woman would
love Enkidu and is quite beautiful.
In
The Tale of Genji (or the sections I
have read so far) I found that Genji was similarly feminized.
I
realize that the feminization comes from completely different ideas, because
these two pieces come from completely different times and cultures. In Japan there is an ancient idea of Bishonen (beautiful men—androgynous-- mostly adolescents back in the day!!)
and men with feminine features are even to this day considered very attractive.
(google search J rock-- If you dare. I wanted to add a picture and chose not too-- You're welcome :D
Also
Genji actually has sex with another man (or I should say boy—creepy pedophile!)
a practice that was actually not that strange in ancient Japan. It seems being male or female was determined
more by their place in society than their sex (Leupp pg. 26). Anyways, this angle could be so fun and filled
with gender and culture!
This
could take so many forms (how exciting!)
I
could compare Genji with Gilgamesh again but this time show how their characters
develop into heroes or don’t ever develop into heroes.
- How does the novel differ from myth (or epic) in showing heroes?
- In both of these I could explore how the fact that The Tale of Genji was written by a woman for women.
- I could also compare The Tale of Genji to The Pillow Book which was also written by a woman around the same time and place.
There
are countless ideas I could explore just using The Tale of Genji, I don’t even need Gilgamesh or any other main text. The novel is like 1,000 pages, extremely
complex and still has a huge impact on Japanese culture!
Some
Sources---
Keene, Donald. Japanese Literature: An Introduction
for Western readers. Charles E. Turtle Company.
Rutland, Vermont and Tokyo. 1955.
Leupp, Gary P. Male Colors: The Construction of Homosexuality in Tokugawa
Japan. University
of California Press. Berkley and Los Angeles, California.1999. pp. 26.
Excellent! I really like all of these ideas, though I think you'll need to narrow them down to 2/3 for the essay. I love the compare/contrast idea with Gilgamesh; I'd like to see you use that text in your essay. Everything here, including the sources (and pics of J Rock [curiosity got the best of me]) look good.
ReplyDeleteLet me know if I can answer any questions or help you decide on an approach.